Intermittent Fasting: Separating Fact from Fiction

Many people believe they are "fasting" by simply not eating between dinner and breakfast.

However, true intermittent fasting involves more prolonged periods of food restriction. Popular methods include:

• 16/8: Fast for 16 hours, eat within an 8-hour window.

• 20/4: Fast for 20 hours, eat within a 4-hour window.

• 22/2: Fast for 22 hours, eat within a 2-hour window.

More prolonged fasting protocols include 24-hour fasts, alternate-day fasting (typically a 36-hour fast), and even 72-hour fasts.

Why Do People Fast?

A recent poll revealed that weight loss is the primary reason people are interested in fasting. Other reported benefits include longevity, improved energy, brain function, and reduced inflammation. Let's explore these claims.

Weight Loss and Calorie Deficit

To achieve weight loss, a calorie deficit is essential. Intermittent fasting is a dietary restriction method that can help reduce total energy intake, making it easier to implement than calorie counting or restricting entire food groups.

However, research on the 16/8 diet and weight loss isn't consistently strong, as individuals can still overconsume calories within the 8-hour eating window. To guarantee weight loss with time restriction, longer fasts (like 22 or 24 hours) are often more effective. Combining the 16/8 protocol with smart nutritional choices can also lead to success.

It's important to note that long-term adherence to any dietary intervention, including fasting, can be challenging. Additionally, maintaining lean muscle mass during weight loss is crucial, and haphazard fasting without proper training and protein intake might not be the best approach.

Improved Insulin Sensitivity

Intermittent fasting can improve insulin sensitivity, but it's crucial to understand that any diet that reduces total energy intake and creates a caloric deficit will also improve insulin sensitivity. While calorie restriction paired with fasting shows a slightly greater improvement, it's the overall reduction in energy that is the primary driver. Smart choices regarding protein intake and training around your fasted window can maximise these benefits.

Longevity and Autophagy

The idea of fasting for longevity gained traction from mouse studies on the 16/8 diet, which showed a significant increase in life expectancy. However, human trials have been less conclusive, partly due to the vast difference in lifespan and the ethical limitations of prolonged human fasting.

A key concept linked to longevity and fasting is autophagy, a natural and complex process where cells degrade and recycle their own components. Fasting does improve autophagy, but so do many other factors, including:

• Exercise: Both aerobic and resistance training.

• Polyphenols: Found in fruits, vegetables, and berries.

• Hormones and growth factors: Especially those related to stress response and energy balance (e.g., cortisol, glucagon).

• Sleep and caloric restriction: These are two of the biggest factors influencing autophagy.

While promoting autophagy seems sensible, we need more research to definitively conclude that increased autophagy directly translates to major longevity benefits in humans, as it's a delicately balanced process.

Inflammation and Cognitive Function

Caloric restriction and intermittent fasting can reduce oxidative stress, improve energy metabolism, and regulate inflammatory activation in the body. Again, these benefits are largely linked to reducing the total energy the body has to process.

Regarding cognitive awareness and energy boosts, individual responses vary greatly. Many people struggle with low energy during prolonged fasting, and women, in particular, often report more dysfunction with their energy levels. While the brain can switch to using ketones as fuel, this isn't a guaranteed outcome for everyone.

Interestingly, research suggests that fasting can enhance cognitive function, promote neuroplasticity, and help with resistance to injury and disease. These findings are positive, but more understanding is needed.

The Cons of Fasting

Some research indicates that fasting may increase cortisol levels and affect carbohydrate utilisation in women during their menstrual cycle. It's important to recognise that not everyone will respond to fasting in the same way or experience all the purported benefits.

Personal Experience and Takeaways

The speaker, who practices regular fasting (typically an 8-9 hour feeding window, with occasional 24 or 36-hour fasts), shares a personal experience of using fasting to alleviate GI tract stress. While it was transformative for them, they emphasise that it's not a one-size-fits-all solution.

Key Takeaways:

• If time restriction is a logical and easy-to-implement option for you, it can be a practical way to reduce total energy intake, especially by cutting out evening snacking.

• However, fasting is not magic. Good quality nutritional habits remain crucial.

• If you're aiming for weight loss, ensure you understand how to preserve lean muscle mass and how fasting might impact your training and performance.

• For longevity, prioritise fundamental health practices first: regular exercise (cardiovascular and resistance), a balanced diet rich in fruits and vegetables, weight stability, and good sleep. Don't jump on trends as a "hack" if these foundational elements aren't in place.

• If you have these fundamentals covered and want to explore additional benefits, start with shorter fasts (16 hours), gradually increasing to 24 or 36 hours, and carefully observe how your body responds.

• Be cautious of misleading claims. Many proposed benefits of fasting are actually linked to overall reduced energy intake, not fasting itself.

Intermittent fasting can be a valuable tool when approached thoughtfully and as part of a well-balanced training, sleep, and lifestyle regimen. However, it's essential to understand its nuances and listen to your body, as individual responses can vary significantly.

Like this post? There’s more where that came from